I purchased this product 5+ years ago at a mall and it was my favorite face exfoliator ever. I purchased it again a few months ago online and the consistency wasn't the same, the color was different, and it did absolutely nothing to face not even a slight amount of exfoliating. I complained to them about the product and they said they didn't change the formula and they said they'd send me another one for free so I agreed and maybe I just got a bad one. Nope same exact thing that did nothing. I will never buy from them again. They are overpriced and I swear they just scam on the product.